Showing posts with label hobbes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hobbes. Show all posts

Monday, June 6, 2011

Logic and Emotion: Go With Your Gut Or Listen To Reason?

'Every time a resolve or fine glow of feeling evaporates without bearing fruit, it is worse than a chance lost; it works to hinder future emotions from taking the normal path of discharge'- William James

'Logic is the anatomy of thought'- John Locke


How do we make a decision and then how, when we have made that decision do we know it was the right one?
If we followed our gut as James says and our gut decisions became the norm we would somehow always manage to remain true to ourselves. This may be so, but 'above all to thine own self be true', may do good for me but what about you? If such a case is to be right for you we must trust Rousseau and accept that humans are innately good hence our true impulses and urges will lead to a greater good. On the other hand if Hobbes is correct and humans are innately evil then 'the life of man [will be] solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short'. 

On the other hand can we really detach ourselves from our emotions can we calculate and compute without caring and concerning. I am most definitely a rationalist, a reasoner and logician but surely years of evolution and following our gut has brought us to many a logical conclusion. Every thought is tinged with motive, which then in turn is tinged with emotion. Logic is the sum of emotional averages, the shortest route to your gut without any detours. I think James was on the right track and for every emotion their is a thought and for every thought their is a reason and for every reason their is an emotion, and this emotion is logic, it is the truth, your truth and the truth for all humans.

Peace out.